Answers
When influencer gifting fails, and what works
Gifts nobody asked for often go unposted. Ask first, agree and pay for the post you need, give each creator a code, and re-book the ones who sell.
The question: “We gifted product to creators and got almost nothing back. What actually works?”
Why the parcels went quiet
What works is asking first, agreeing and paying for the post you need, and keeping the creators whose sales show up. A parcel nobody asked for creates no obligation to post: the creator may not want it, and owes you nothing. A thin return is normal. In a 2023 Traackr survey of 305 marketers in the US, UK, France and Germany, 61% said fewer than half of the creators they gifted went on to post.
Silence after delivery is common too. In Modash's 2026 survey of 74 marketers working for ecommerce brands, 90.5% said creators ghost gifting campaigns more often than other collaborations. The code of conduct ISBA and the Influencer Marketing Trade Body wrote for UK practitioners warns that untargeted or unsolicited mass gifting can lead to surpluses and excess consumption.
Ask before you send
Write to each creator first: say why you picked them and ask whether they would like to try the product. Say what a post would involve and what you would pay for it, so a yes means something. Send only to those who say yes, in the right shade, size or skin type, and agree what happens next before anything ships.
Gifting does not get you out of the ad rules. The October 2026 ASA, CAP and CMA guide counts free products as payment even with no obligation to post, so any post must make clear from the start that it is an ad: an "Ad" label at the beginning is the simplest way. If you expect a post rather than hope for one, the ASA may treat that expectation as control, which brings the CAP Code in as well. Audiences prefer it that way: in the ASA's research, 80% of the UK online population said they prefer influencers to be clear about when they are advertising.
Pay for the posts you need
If you need content, buy it. Agree the format, the date and how long the post stays up, pay a fee, and send the product on top. Pay the fee once the post is live, so a no-show costs you a parcel rather than a fee. Gifting still has a place, as a way to find creators who genuinely like the product, but treat it as the first step rather than the campaign.
Put it in writing. In the same Modash survey, nearly half of marketers used no contract for gifting and another 31.1% relied on informal emails. ISBA publishes influencer contract templates for the whole industry to use, including one for one-off or low-value campaigns.
Measure each creator, then double down
Give every creator their own discount code and link, and read Shopify's Sales by discount codes report creator by creator. Treat the numbers as a guide: some buyers never use a code, and extensions such as PayPal's Honey apply any working code they find at checkout.
Re-book the creators who sell and stop sending to the ones who do not. When a post works, ask the creator for permission to run it as a Meta partnership ad, and put ad money behind content that has already shown it sells.
Where Autone fits
Autone does the asking from your own Gmail or Outlook: it finds creators, writes to them, follows up, collects each creator's address so you can send the product, and tracks each post. You approve every creator, fee and payment. You set each creator's fee, plus product and postage, and each creator's own discount code shows their orders in your Shopify.
When Autone is the wrong choice
If you want to keep sending parcels with no conversation first, Autone is the wrong fit: it writes to each creator and agrees the post before anything ships. It sends nothing you have not approved, so you stay involved in every email and payment; if you would rather hand the whole programme over, an agency may suit you better. It is also built for Shopify brands.
Questions
If we asked for nothing in return, is a gifted post still an ad?
Yes. The CMA's guidance for brands says that even if you do not control the content or ask for anything, posts must be labelled as ads, and that gifts should go out with instructions to label any resulting post "Ad".
Is "gifted" a good enough label?
No. The October 2026 ASA, CAP and CMA guide advises against "gift", "gifted" and "PR" because research shows they are not clear to people. Use "Ad" at the start.
Should we chase creators who got a parcel?
Once, briefly, if you had agreed something. In Modash's survey, 74.3% of marketers already followed up two or three times after delivery, and 90.5% still said gifting gets ghosted more than other collaborations. The fix is agreeing the post before you send.
Sources
- Traackr, State of Influencer Product Seeding survey of 305 marketers from brands and agencies in the US, France, Germany and the UK (reported June 2023): 61% said less than half of the influencers receiving gifted products actually post. (traackr.com, checked 2026-11-11)
- Modash, "The State of Influencer Gifting in 2026" (22 May 2026; 74 marketers, primarily in-house at ecommerce brands or at agencies serving them, mainly in the US, Europe and Asia): 90.5% say creators ghost gifting campaigns more often than other types of collaboration; nearly half do not use contracts at all and another 31.1% rely on informal email agreements; 74.3% follow up twice or three times after delivery. (modash.io, checked 2026-11-11)
- ISBA and IMTB, Influencer Marketing Code of Conduct (version 4, November 2024, aimed at UK practitioners), clause 10.5: excessive product gifting, such as untargeted or unsolicited mass distribution of products, can lead to surpluses and excessive consumption. (isba.org.uk, checked 2026-11-11)
- ASA, CAP and CMA, "Influencers' guide to making clear that ads are ads" (October 2026): free products count as payment whether requested or unsolicited and even with no obligation to post; related content must make clear it is advertising, ideally with an "Ad" label upfront; even an expectation that content will be created, as opposed to a hope that it might be, could be seen as control for the ASA's purposes; advises against "Gift/Gifted" and "PR" labels because research shows they are not clear to users; the ASA's research found 80% of the UK online population prefer it when influencers are clear about when they are advertising. (asa.org.uk, checked 2026-11-11)
- CMA, "Social media endorsements: guidance for brands" (updated 28 August 2025): even if the business does not control the content or ask for anything in return, ads must be labelled as ads; brands sending free gifts should include clear instructions that any resulting content must be labelled "Ad". (gov.uk, checked 2026-11-11)
- ISBA, "ISBA Influencer Contract Templates": the contracts are available for the entire industry to use; the micro-influencer template is for a one-off or low-value campaign. (isba.org.uk, checked 2026-11-11)
- Shopify Help Center, Sales reports: the "Sales by discount codes" report shows the number of orders and total sales for each discount code. (help.shopify.com, checked 2026-11-11)
- Honey (part of PayPal): pops up at checkout to search for coupons and, if it finds working codes, automatically applies one to the cart. (joinhoney.com, checked 2026-11-11)
- Modash, "How to set up influencer discount codes" (September 2026): some followers buy without entering the code, so pair codes with tracking links. (modash.io, checked 2026-11-11)
- Meta Help Center, "How to create a partnership ad": partnership ads let advertisers run ads with creators; the creator grants permission, for example by sharing an ad code, and the advertiser can then boost that content. (help.instagram.com, checked 2026-11-11)
30-day free trial, no card required. Month-to-month on every plan. No annual contract is sold. See pricing, or read another answer.
Something here wrong or out of date? Tell us at support@autone.app and we will correct it.